Are loyalty card discounts really saving me money, or are they just a marketing trick

Are Loyalty Card Discounts Really Saving You Money, or Are They Just a Marketing Trick?

Loyalty cards are a common feature in many supermarkets and retail stores, promising discounts, rewards, and exclusive offers to regular customers. But are these loyalty card discounts genuinely saving you money, or are they just a clever marketing trick designed to keep you coming back? Let's delve into the reality behind loyalty card schemes and how they impact your wallet.

**The Appeal of Loyalty Cards**

Loyalty cards are designed to reward repeat customers. They often offer points for every purchase, which can be redeemed for discounts, free products, or other perks. The idea is to create a sense of value and savings, encouraging customers to shop more frequently at the same store.

**The Reality of Loyalty Card Discounts**

While loyalty cards can offer genuine savings, there are several factors to consider:

1. **Price Inflation Before Discounts**

   - Some supermarkets have been found to inflate prices shortly before offering a loyalty card discount, making the discount seem more significant than it actually is¹. For example, a product might be priced at £10, then increased to £15 just before a "special" loyalty discount brings it back down to £10. This tactic can mislead customers into thinking they are getting a better deal than they are.

2. **Dual Pricing Systems**

   - Many supermarkets now use dual pricing systems, where loyalty card holders get a lower price than non-members. While this can offer savings, it also means that non-members might be paying inflated prices². This system can create a perception of savings for loyalty card holders, even if the actual prices are not the best available.

3. **Encouraging Higher Spending**

   - Loyalty programs often encourage customers to spend more to earn more points or reach the next reward tier. This can lead to increased spending on items you might not have otherwise purchased¹. For instance, you might buy an extra item just to get double points, even if you don't need it.

4. **Data Collection and Privacy Concerns**

   - Loyalty cards are also a tool for collecting data on your shopping habits. This data is valuable to retailers as it helps them tailor their marketing strategies and promotions. While this can lead to personalized offers, it also raises privacy concerns³.

**Real-Life Examples**

- **Tesco and Sainsbury's**: Investigations have shown that these supermarkets sometimes increase prices before offering loyalty card discounts, making the discounts appear more substantial than they are².

- **Boots and Superdrug**: These retailers have been criticized for similar practices, with significant price hikes just before loyalty discounts are applied⁶.

**How to Make the Most of Loyalty Cards**

Despite these concerns, loyalty cards can still offer genuine savings if used wisely:

1. **Compare Prices**

   - Always compare prices with other stores, both with and without loyalty card discounts. Use price comparison websites and apps to ensure you're getting the best deal.

2. **Be Mindful of Spending**

   - Avoid the temptation to buy unnecessary items just to earn points. Stick to your shopping list and only purchase what you need.

3. **Understand the Value of Points**

   - Know the value of the points you are earning and how they can be redeemed. Some loyalty programs offer better value than others, so it's worth understanding how to maximize your rewards.

4. **Use Cashback Apps**

   - Combine loyalty card discounts with cashback apps like Shopmium and Ibotta to increase your savings².

**Conclusion**

Loyalty card discounts can offer real savings, but it's essential to be aware of the potential pitfalls. By understanding how these programs work and being mindful of your spending, you can make the most of loyalty cards without falling for marketing tricks. Always compare prices, be cautious of inflated discounts, and use loyalty programs to your advantage.

I hope this helps 

V xxx

¹: Example from general supermarket practices.

²: Example from Tesco and Sainsbury's.

³: Example from data collection practices.

⁶: Example from Boots and Superdrug.

Source: Conversation with Copilot, 14/09/2024

(1) Loyalty cards: do they save you money? - Money Dashboard. https://www.moneydashboard.com/blog/loyalty-cards-do-they-save-you-money.

(2) The ethics of loyalty cards: dodgy pricing and data collection. https://www.ethicalconsumer.org/retailers/ethics-loyalty-cards.

(3) Sainsbury's and Tesco loyalty card prices not as good as they seem .... https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-66813908.

(4) The big chains using loyalty card discounts for ‘rip-off’ prices .... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/loyalty-card-tesco-boots-which-member-discount-b2600019.html.

(5) What do supermarkets REALLY do with your loyalty card data?. https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/bills/article-12190197/Supermarket-loyalty-cards-big-discounts-expense-privacy.html.

(6) Are loyalty card changes good or bad for your money? - Reader's Digest. https://www.readersdigest.co.uk/money/are-loyalty-card-changes-good-or-bad-for-your-money.

(7) How to Make Your Loyalty Program Pay Off - Harvard Business Review. https://hbr.org/2021/10/how-to-make-your-loyalty-program-pay-off.

(8) Do loyalty programs really work? What the research says - Tremendous. https://bing.com/search?q=loyalty+card+discounts+really+saving+money+or+marketing+trick.

(9) Why I hate vouchers, loyalty schemes and idiotic marketing gimmicks. https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/saving/article-2757920/RICHARD-BROWNING-I-hate-vouchers-loyalty-schemes-idiotic-marketing-gimmicks.html.

(10) Do loyalty programs really work? What the research says - Tremendous. https://www.tremendous.com/blog/do-loyalty-programs-really-work-what-the-research-says/.

(11) Do loyalty cards really save you money? | This Morning - ITVX. https://www.itv.com/thismorning/articles/do-loyalty-cards-really-save-you-money.